I watched the DVD of Sybil the other night. I remember when it was on TV--I must've wandered in a few times because I did remember some of the scenes, and then I read the book when I was in the 8th grade. The book is pretty mind-blowing--I had nightmares about it. I'm sure many of you know the story already, but it's a true story about a woman who developed a severe case of multiple personality disorder as the result of terrible childhood abuse from her mother. There are a couple of chapters in the book which talk about the mother who was just...a monster. I hate to say that about someone who suffered herself from mental illness (she was diagnosed as schizophrenic but she and her husband poo-poohed the diagnosis and their church was highly suspicious of the psychiatric community in general). But her schizophrenia notwithstanding, she obviously KNEW what she was doing was wrong, because she lied about it and tried to hide it.
Anyway, the movie is very powerful, especially considering it was a TV-movie. It could easily compete with any cinematic release--it's that good. Sally Field is unbelievable as Sybil--she is riveting. And since it was a TV-movie, the abuse isn't really shown graphically on the screen--a lot is implied. Notwithstanding there are some sequences that I'm amazed were allowed to air on TV--the mother does some truly horrific things to the child that I can't bear even to write about. I had to not-watch one scene, it was just too disturbing. I can't believe this stuff got past the censors. One of the more powerful scenes that I can actually discuss is a dream sequence--Sybil dreams about finding a litter of abandoned kittens in a trash can. When she picks them up in a box she sees the mother cat who's dead but still hissing and growling at her. She picks up the kittens and runs away but no matter where she runs she hears the mother cat. She's running through a field (lugging the box full of kittens)--her dad and grandmother are waving to her from the field, but she still hears the mother cat. She runs into a stable and the cat is still right nearby, growling viciously. It's terrifying--CGI could probably make it seem more realistic nowadays but the concept, the cat's relentlessness, is what makes it so powerful.
The one weak part of the movie is the inclusion of this fictional love interest, played by Brad Davis. It feels so forced, so "okay, gotta have a love interest," so commercial and it falls flat--every minute he's on screen I was impatient. It doesn't help that his character is by turns annoyingly pushy, and cheesy. He's that classic '70s urban-funky-"I'm so quirky--love me!" type, complete with clown makeup and suspenders. It's like Jesus from Godspell is trying to hit on Sybil. But there's one interesting thing in his scenes--he has a young son who picks up on Sybil's disorder and tells her (when one of the other personalities is in control) "you're not Sybil..." and later on tells his dad "Sybil is full of people." Since the father and son characters are fabricated it loses its punch but as a dramatic device it's still interesting.
*Shudder* I was going to re-read the book the next time I was at my mom's but now I think I'll pass. I don't think I can handle it again.
Anyway, the movie is very powerful, especially considering it was a TV-movie. It could easily compete with any cinematic release--it's that good. Sally Field is unbelievable as Sybil--she is riveting. And since it was a TV-movie, the abuse isn't really shown graphically on the screen--a lot is implied. Notwithstanding there are some sequences that I'm amazed were allowed to air on TV--the mother does some truly horrific things to the child that I can't bear even to write about. I had to not-watch one scene, it was just too disturbing. I can't believe this stuff got past the censors. One of the more powerful scenes that I can actually discuss is a dream sequence--Sybil dreams about finding a litter of abandoned kittens in a trash can. When she picks them up in a box she sees the mother cat who's dead but still hissing and growling at her. She picks up the kittens and runs away but no matter where she runs she hears the mother cat. She's running through a field (lugging the box full of kittens)--her dad and grandmother are waving to her from the field, but she still hears the mother cat. She runs into a stable and the cat is still right nearby, growling viciously. It's terrifying--CGI could probably make it seem more realistic nowadays but the concept, the cat's relentlessness, is what makes it so powerful.
The one weak part of the movie is the inclusion of this fictional love interest, played by Brad Davis. It feels so forced, so "okay, gotta have a love interest," so commercial and it falls flat--every minute he's on screen I was impatient. It doesn't help that his character is by turns annoyingly pushy, and cheesy. He's that classic '70s urban-funky-"I'm so quirky--love me!" type, complete with clown makeup and suspenders. It's like Jesus from Godspell is trying to hit on Sybil. But there's one interesting thing in his scenes--he has a young son who picks up on Sybil's disorder and tells her (when one of the other personalities is in control) "you're not Sybil..." and later on tells his dad "Sybil is full of people." Since the father and son characters are fabricated it loses its punch but as a dramatic device it's still interesting.
*Shudder* I was going to re-read the book the next time I was at my mom's but now I think I'll pass. I don't think I can handle it again.